Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/dh_ueu9qi/beta.frontlineclub.com/wp-content/themes/frontline3.6/functions.php:1) in /home/dh_ueu9qi/beta.frontlineclub.com/wp-includes/feed-rss2.php on line 8
media rights – Frontline Club http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com Championing Independent Journalism Tue, 04 Sep 2012 14:51:01 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 Two Azeri Bloggers receive prison terms http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/two_azeri_bloggers_receive_prison_terms/ Thu, 12 Nov 2009 00:52:17 +0000 http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/dev/?p=2885 On 11th November, despite huge international and internal pressure, Sabail District Court of Baku presided by Justice Araz Huseynov convicted two Azerbaijani bloggers Emin Milli and Adnan Hajizade on controversial hooliganism charges. Though many observers and law experts I met during trial considered the process actually won by defense lawyers who in turn, had caught state witnesses on perjury and contradictions and presented many substantial evidences such as these ones, Emin and Adnan received jail sentences of 2,5 and 2 years respectively. No rationale was offered to explain term difference.

The defense plans to appeal the verdict in higher instances till the European Court of Human Rights. International community has strongly condemned the case as political one and Amnesty International has already adopted the bloggers as "prisoners of conscience."

Emin Milli, 30, and Adnan Hajizade, 26, were assaulted and beaten while dining in a downtown Baku restaurant and then detained for hooliganism on early July this year.

Note: this piece was posted with a back date

]]>
Barack Obama singles out Azerbaijan http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/barack_obama_singles_out_azerbaijan/ Mon, 04 May 2009 18:30:39 +0000 http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/dev/?p=2870 In his statement in honor of World Press Freedom Day, U.S. President Barack Obama singled out Azerbaijan among the "corner[s] of the globe" where journalists are in jail or being actively harassed:

In every corner of the globe, there are journalists in jail or being actively harassed: from Azerbaijan to Zimbabwe, Burma to Uzbekistan, Cuba to Eritrea.

The statement went mostly unnoticed in Azerbaijani media and public more preoccupied with deadly rampage at State Oil Academy which left 13 people dead. However, local oppositional newspaper Yeni Musavat in an article about this statement describes an infamous image of Zimbabwe that persists in Azerbaijan and asks:

…Zimbabwe is infamous here, as it is infamous in the world. This country is infamous for its hyperinflation, massive unemployement, massive famine and widespred illnesses. Now, it seems Zimbabwe has problems with media also.

However, let’s see what is more fair: a comparison of our country to Zimbabwe, or mentioning of Zimbabwe together with Azerbaijan. That is, who should be offended when compared to other.

]]>
Leading Azeri Online News Portal Shuts Down http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/leading_azeri_online_news_portal_shuts_down/ http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/leading_azeri_online_news_portal_shuts_down/#comments Fri, 20 Feb 2009 16:20:21 +0000 http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/dev/?p=2860 Not so long ago, on 12 February, Anar Mamedkhanov, founder of Day.az, leading Azeri media outlet, and one of the biggest online news portals in Caucasus warned his Armenian colleagues:

Gentlemen, wake up, it is XXI century, year 2009 (just in case to remind you of), only day.az with the quantity of its visits and views surpasses all Armenian and pro-Armenian websites altogether a dozen times, and this popularity and reputation are acquired by years of painstaking work, objectivity of information and pluralism of opinions.

Yet, on the night of 18 February, just after six days, day.az was shut down, and this is why you have to visit Google cash, in order to find the original of aforementioned Mamedkhanov quote.

At first, day.az and its sister sites (e.g. dayaz.com and today.az) displayed a comment that the website is shut down for “unknown reasons”; then – “due to technical problems”; and then finally – “project is closed”. Now the comment reads: “Site is temporarily unavailable due to technical problems” and “will be back on 25th February.” Besides, as Osman Gunduz of Azerbaijan Internet Forum reported, details about day.az was surprisingly deleted from the National Domain Database [UPDATE: Now, they have reappeared.  For more, visit whois.az ].

A correspondent from Azadliq Radio, an Azeri version of RFE/RL, made a visit to Day.az headquarters and found only one employee who in turn had told them:

Yes, they have closed both day.az radio and day.az website. i am an editor with the website. I don’t know what the reason is. There are so many reasons in the world… Everyone has left. I am alone in the office. I can’t say anything about who closed and why closed [day.az]. In the afternoon, at dinner time they said that, it is closed and that is all.

Speaking hours after the incident Anar Mamedkhanov told local agencies that closure of day.az “was connected with technical causes". “There were some technical failures in the website. They are being eliminated. The staff of the website will not change,” he said and added that website would restart within a week and with a number of changes, and declined to give further comments.

Armenian colleagues of Mamedkhanov, particularly, panorama.am reported the news as “Azeri media outlet was shut down for dissidence” and tied it to latest bleak report about Azerbaijani economy published on the eve of the closure. Ilgar Mammadov, Azerbaijani political analyst talked about “decision of governing circles, motivated by monarchic aspirations, to close day.az, which was a more succesful Azerbaijani news project providing relatively objective, complete and more pluralist material feed in [Azerbaijani] Internet”.  Elmira Akhundova, an Azeri MP stated that she exactly knows [how?]: “This issue is purely technical and is stemming from a problem with a transmitter in the US”.

However, Regnum.ru, which apparently was first to break the news, had more accurate wording:

By the way, as correspondent of IA Regnum was told by a competent source, the website [of day.az] is temporarily blocked due to political motives related to a publication of an interview, mentioning somehow Russian issues.

And I’d say yes, this is the case! As Turan Information Agency reported, day.az irritated some circles in Russia, especially for coverage of Russian-Georgian conflict in August 2008 and recently day.az published an interview with a disgraced Russian oligarch Boris Berezovsky in which the former blamed incumbent Russian PM Vladimir Putin for corruption, accused him of accumulating $40 billion dollars in foreign accounts and being interested in conflicts in Caucasus. As Turan continues, the next day after the interview appeared in Internet, the representatives of Presidential Administration were looking for the contacts of administrators of the site.

What happened afterwards is merely a mystery, but Hikmet Hadjy-zadeh, an Azeri political analyst had such a colourful version in one local forum:

Last unconfirmed report about the closure of day.az

Website is closed because of the interview with Berezovsky published there, in which Berezovsky talked critically about incumbent Kremlin leadership.

They phoned from the Kremlin to our white house and there were many emotions.

Then our white house-dwellers summoned Anar Mamedkhanov and strictly ordered him to occupy himself with exclusively legislative activities (yes, you are an MP – did forget it? – and do what MPs do)

And forget about the website.

Forever or not – don’t know.

Official reaction to the closure of day.az complicated the issue more. For Ali Hasanov, head of the Socio-Political Department of the Presidential Administration told one local TV

I have no information about the closure of this website. In any case, the administration of the website knows the reasons better. But, how can the Azerbaijani Government shut down a website?

however, asked about Berezovsky connection, he replied:

We are a friendly country with Russia and can’t be indifferent to any information disseminated about its head of state or government. But I think that any site can be closed for such a material.

Yes, speaking merely, as Thoughts on the Roads says, Putin reportedly called the Azerbaijani President personally and demanded the closure of the site. 

Ironically, not long ago day.az published an interview with a Russian political analyst who claimed that the real cause of the Russian-Georgian conflict in August 2008 was the Georgian President Saakashvili’s referring to PM Vladimir Putin as “Lilliputin&rd
quo;. So why, you can ask, day.az didn’t learn a lesson from Putin’s response to Georgian President? Obviously, Georgian themselves didn’t learn anything! According to Eternal Remont, one of my favourite blogs, Georgia enters Eurovision Song Contest 2009 with a song called “We don’t wanna put in”.

So next thing to guess is either Eurovision to be closed or Georgia to get a Hollywood-style sequel?

UPDATE: IA Regnum reports: Termination of activities of Day.az, the most visited Internet resource of Central Asia and Caucasus starting from 18 February, has been caused by serious political mistakes made by employees of this information resource recently, IA Regnum was told by a source in the Azerbaijani government who wished to remain anonymous. In particular, according to the source, website published materials, not helpful to the development of Azerbaijani-Russian and Azerbaijani-Turkish relations. 

]]>
http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/leading_azeri_online_news_portal_shuts_down/feed/ 2
Azerbaijan bans foreign broadcasts while preparing for a constitutional referendum http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/azerbaijan_bans_foreign_broadcasts_while_preparing_for_a_constitutional_referendum/ Wed, 07 Jan 2009 19:39:04 +0000 http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/dev/?p=2859 In the last days of 2008, Azerbaijan’s
National Council for Television and Radio has banned international radio
stations from broadcasting on national frequencies
. The decision went
effective on the 1st of January removing three radio stations from
FM band – VOA, BBC and Azadliq (“Liberty”), RFE/RL’s Azeri service. With
another decision, Parliament
of Azerbaijan approved a referendum
to be held early next year to remove
the time limit on presidential terms. Currently a person can be elected to the
office of the President of Azerbaijan only twice, whereas ruling party wants
the country to hold a referendum to eliminate any such limits to open the way
for the possible re-election of the incumbent president, Ilham Aliyev.

In a country with a tight government control over media, the
ban on the international radio stations were seen by some as an attack on the
last remnants of free speech. Particularly, the ban of Azadliq met a protest
from politically active segments of the society. Mammad Suleymanov,
a left-wing columnist from local Bizim
Yol
newspaper
, called Azadliq “the last Bastille of free speech [in
Azerbaijan]” and added that the government took this Bastille very easily.
According to him “everyone starting from taxi drivers to housewives were
listening to Azadliq and only this was enough argument for closing it”.

International reactions (mostly of regret and condemnation)
to this move of the Azeri government continue to arrive and Azerbaijan
International keeps a good record of them
. Azerbaijan International also
published the letter of one Azadliq
journalist describing the last minutes of the radio. Azadliq completed its programs on FM band with overture
from Koroglu
, the most patriotic
and the most beloved Azeri opera composed by Uzeyir Hajibekov. While
Sözün Düzü posted a video from YouTube,
where a group of Azeri youth was filmed marking New Year together with those
last minutes of Azadliq. One of the youth
interviewed in the video says that he had come to share the grief of Azadliq,
while other comments that “they can close Azadliq (“Liberty”), but Liberty will
surely come to this country.”

Tabula
Rasa writes
that “they silence the alternative voices” and asks “Why now?”
Then he gives three hypothetical answers to his question: (a) either the
government “prepares to sign a capitulatory peace on Nagorno-Karabakh”; (b) or
they “want to hold the referendum without any troubles”, or (c) “as the price
of oil fell four times, the economy is in a bad condition, therefore government
tries to prevent any possible awakening in minds”.

With three international radios silenced on national
frequencies, the country heads for a nationwide referendum to decide whether to
lift constitutional obstacles to re-election of someone for the office of the
President more than two times. With the parliamentary proposal made
on the 19th of December
, Constitutional Court’s approval five
days later, and the decision of the Parliament made
on 26th of December
, the whole procedure took only seven days,
and the referendum is set for March 18, 2009.

Meanwhile, Ali Hasanov, head of the
Socio-Political Department of the Presidential Administration, expressed his
regret
that this move of Azerbaijani government is interpreted as banning
the broadcast of these radios in Azerbaijan. According to his words, “it won’t
be difficult for a listener to switch from FM band to short waves, and those
who want will listen to these radios in any case.” The only reason behind this
move was the laws of Azerbaijan which states that national frequencies can be
operated only by national companies and Azerbaijani citizens, Ali Hasanov told
to Day.az, main Russian-language Internet news
portal of Azerbaijan.

]]>
Constitutional Court at the focus of controversies http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/constitutional_court_at_the_focus_of_controversies/ http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/constitutional_court_at_the_focus_of_controversies/#comments Wed, 24 Dec 2008 20:39:03 +0000 http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/dev/?p=2858 The highest judicial instance in Azerbaijan, the Constitutional Court "is considering amendments that would ban the broadcast or publication of video, audio, or photographs of any person without his or her prior approval, except in yet-to-be defined special cases", reports RFE/RL


According to local media law expert Alasgar Mammadli, if these amendments get approval, the situation will look like this:

If a journalist catches a member of parliament sleeping during proceedings — a dereliction of duty the public should be informed of, he said — the amendment would require the journalist to wake the MP, ask his permission to shoot, wait for him to fall asleep again, and then push the record button.


Moreover, if someone refuses to give an interview, or comment on any issue, journalists won’t have any rights to publish the footage, where that person will say: "I don’t want to talk to you".


Constitutional Court is at the focus of controversies these days, because of another case before it. Recently, the Parliament of Azerbaijan decided to lift presidential term limits and asked the Court to rule about its constitutionality. Currently a person can be elected to the office of the President of Azerbaijan only twice, whereas ruling party wants the country to hold a referendum to eliminate any such limits. 

As anticipated, on 24 December, the Court ruled to allow the requested referendum. Chairman of the Court, Farhad Abdullayev, said that there were no legal obstacles to such a referendum. If approved, these amendments could clear the way for Ilham Aliyev, the incumbent President of Azerbaijan to run for a third presidential term. He was elected as the President in 2003, and re-elected in October this year.

Meanwhile, the police broke up the protest by some opposition activists who tried to hold a demonstration in front of the Counstitutional Court building. 

Below is the amateur video from the protest.

]]>
http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/constitutional_court_at_the_focus_of_controversies/feed/ 1