Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/dh_ueu9qi/beta.frontlineclub.com/wp-content/themes/frontline3.6/functions.php:1) in /home/dh_ueu9qi/beta.frontlineclub.com/wp-includes/feed-rss2.php on line 8
International Criminal Court – Frontline Club http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com Championing Independent Journalism Mon, 03 Sep 2012 14:13:52 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 ForesightNews world briefing: upcoming events 15 – 21 August http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/foresightnews_world_briefing_upcoming_events_15-21_august/ http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/foresightnews_world_briefing_upcoming_events_15-21_august/#respond Thu, 11 Aug 2011 12:02:00 +0000 http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/dev/?p=290 A weekly round up of world events from Monday, 15 August to Sunday, 21 August from ForesightNews

Former Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak returns to court on Monday. Along with his sons Alaa and Gamal he appears charged with premeditated murder in connection with the deaths of protesters during the 25 January revolution.

Monday also sees the publication of Japan’s Q2 stats. The country’s GDP shrank 3.7 per cent in Q1, largely attributed to the 11 March disasters, and a similar decline is expected as the country copes with power shortages following the nuclear crisis.

It’s the turn of Europe to brace itself for GDP figures on Tuesday, with the official publication of the euro zone GDP figures. Publication comes amid recent fears growing over the global economy and the recent agreement to give Greece a second bailout.

Eyes are drawn to the International Criminal Court on Wednesday, as former UN employee Callixte Mbarushimana appears charged with five counts of crimes against humanity in the Democratic Republic of Congo in 2009. Mbarushimana is also believed to have been involved in the Rwandan genocide, but has never been charged over the atrocities.

Angola also hosts a summit of the Southern African Development Community in Luanda on Wednesday. The two-day affair is expected to focus on Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe and his refusal to fully implement the Global Political Agreement, as well as the recent fuel protests in Malawi.

Pope Benedict XVI makes an apostolic journey to Madrid on Thursday, to attend a gathering of Catholic youth to mark World Youth Day. Visit includes a Holy Mass at Cuatro Vientos Airport on 21 August.

In the UK, thousands of students learn what their future holds when A Level results are published on Thursday, and students scramble for (often) oversubscribed university places.

Friday sees the last day in office for Romanian Health Minister Attila Cseke, who tendered his resignation earlier this month following a dispute over funds for his brief. Under Romanian law Cseke had to continue his post for 15 days at a maximum until Prime Minister Emil Boc nominated a successor.

On Saturday the UN Panel of inquiry, led by former New Zealand Prime Minister Geoffrey Palmer, is expected to release its report. The report has been delayed several times, most recently from 27 July, and could well be postponed again.

The 2011 Homeless World Cup begins on Sunday, giving homeless and socially marginalised players from across the world the opportunity to represent their country at the beautiful game.

On Sunday a national memorial service takes place in Norway, commemorating the 77 people who were killed in the 22 July Oslo bombing and Utoya shootings. Ceremony takes place in Oslo Spektrum and was announced by Prime Minister Jens Stoltenberg ‘to take care of each other and show compassion’.

]]>
http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/foresightnews_world_briefing_upcoming_events_15-21_august/feed/ 0
Progress in Darfur Peace Talks http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/progress_in_darfur_peace_talks/ http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/progress_in_darfur_peace_talks/#respond Tue, 17 Feb 2009 06:12:58 +0000 http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/dev/?p=4000 Good news emerging from Doha where members of the Justice and Equality Movement are poised to sign an agreement with the Sudanese government that could pave the way to peace talks on Darfur. The deal includes an agreement to end attacks on people living in aid camps and an exchange of prisoners. It is designed as a declaration of good intentions and the first step to further talks on Darfur, where the six-year conflict is now taking on the shape of a long-term war which isn’t going to go away any time soon.
Of course good intentions are few and far between in Doha, despite today’s planned signing. For Jem, the issue of prisoners is crucial. Dozens were rounded up and sentenced to death last year after Jem’s assault on Omdurman, across the Nile from the capital Khartoum. They included Abdel Aziz el-Nur Ashr, the half brother of Jem’a leader Khalil Ibrahim. The prospect of his release is driving Jem’s presence in Doha.
At the same time, judges at the International Criminal Court are due any day to issue a warrant for the arrest of Omar al Bashir, the Sudanese president. A deal is his olive branch and two fingers to the world. I’m a reasonable guy, it says, ready to talk peace. Arrest him and any deal collapses.
Besides good intentions, any real peace deal with need many other parties on board. First there are the other rebel factions. Then there are the Arab groups who have also suffered during years of war and drought. Most of the fighting for the past few months has been between Arab groups. Any deal without them will leave an important constituency on the sideline. Then there is the cross-border proxy war between Chad and Sudan.
Real peace will have to address all the different but interlinked conflicts that comprise what we know as the Darfur war. Getting Jem – which had previously steered clear of talks and deals – into the same room as the government has to be a step in the right direction. But the example of the failed Darfur Peace Agreement shows that all of Darfur’s people have to have a say in forging the peace. There is a lot of work to do yet.

]]>
http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/progress_in_darfur_peace_talks/feed/ 0
Saving Darfur: The International Criminal Court and the Language of Righting Wrongs http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/saving_darfur_the_international_criminal_court_and_the_language_of_righting_wrongs/ http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/saving_darfur_the_international_criminal_court_and_the_language_of_righting_wrongs/#comments Mon, 09 Feb 2009 11:45:46 +0000 http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/dev/?p=3996
Police wait for President Bashir to arrive in El Fasher last year

Fighters of the Lord’s Resistance Army, Uganda’s shadowy rebel cult, have forced more than 130,000 people from their homes in the Democratic Republic of Congo since Congolese soldiers joined Ugandan and Southern Sudanese forces in launching an all-out assault on guerilla hide-outs before Christmas. Hundreds of civilians have died at the hands of the LRA.

But just over two years ago, LRA negotiators were days from signing a peace deal with the Ugandan government to end Africa’s most brutal war – two decades of bloodshed horrific even by the skewed yardstick of the world’s most violent continent. Joseph Kony, the reclusive LRA leader, cried off sick with diarrhoea and never signed the deal.

The reason, according to one of his closest lieutenants who defected just over a year ago, was that he feared trial and execution by the International Criminal Court in The Hague. Now his loyal footsoldiers – many of them snatched as children – are waging their brutal war once again.

Kony may be wrong about the risk of execution – the ICC doesn’t kill criminals – but his example is instructive in thinking about Darfur as the world waits for the Sudanese president, Omar al Bashir, to be indicted on war crimes charges. The decision of the ICC judges on whether to charge Bashir is expected in days or weeks with massive consequences for Darfur, Sudan and Africa in general.

With peace talks between the Sudanese government and rebels of the Justice and Equality Movement starting in Qatar today, why do anything to disrupt the faint chance of peace in Darfur? (A bit like arresting Martin McGuinness during talks that led to the Good Friday agreement, is how one western diplomat in Khartoum put it). Or is the whole thing a cynical plot by Khartoum to make the ICC judges think again.

Either way, criminalising a head of state can only raise temperatures in an already volatile country, putting peacekeeping operations at risk and forcing aid agencies on to a defensive footing. A shaky peace deal with the south, signed in 2005 ending more than 20 years of civil war, will weaken further under the pressure. And the Darfuri rebels could become sufficiently emboldened to have another crack at the capital, Khartoum.

Against that is the need to hold leaders to account for their actions. If war crimes have been committed in Darfur then the people responsible should be prosecuted.

This debate – framed as justice versus peace in the Darfur context – is nothing new. Humanitarian actors have to grapple with similar issues in every theatre of misery. Generally the aid agencies on the ground come down on the consequentialist, pragmatic side of the argument, and opt for a position that allows them to continue doling out sacks of food, medicine and water pumps. For them, questions of justice and rights and responsibilities come second to saving lives. (Although their language often uses terms such as "rights" and "responsibilities" they are actually used as a shorthand for consequentialist positions, where ends are more important than means. See rule utilitarianism, for example.)

The further you travel from Africa, the more rights-based theories of ethics take over. The issues look much more black and white from New York, London or the Hague. And there is no doubt that a proper, long-lasting peace can only come with a just settlement – and that might very well involved carting people such as Kony and Bashir off to the ICC. But it might very well also reduce the possibility of peace being reached at all. That, of course, doesn’t matter if you are a following a justice or rights-based deontological approach: Means overtake ends in importance. The right thing to do is the right thing to do, regardless of whether it actually achieves peace.

So much of this comes down to worldview. And the two approaches are ultimately incompatible. The debate over the role of the Save Darfur coalition is one such example of how the two sides are speaking different, untranslatable languages. Advocates of justice-based arguments are unlikely to be swayed by appeals to the negative consequences of taking Bashir to the ICC, for example. They have already decided that consequences are less important than justice.

At times these differences flare into outright hostility. For a summary of positions you can read Michael Kleinman, whose background is with aid agencies, and David Sullivan, of the Enough project.

Not only are the positions incompatible, the two sides cannot even talk to each other. At the very least they need a common ethical language so that the opposing worldviews can express their differences in terms that the opposition can understand. In practice many people use a mix of deontological and consequentialist ethics for their everyday lives (it’s wrong to lie, except in certain circumstances, such as to avoid hurting someone’s feelings, say) and the challenge is to find a similar framework for social ethics, that can accommodate both worldviews, allowing the two sides to express their differences in a common language.

So for me, this is not about picking sides, it’s about trying to reconcile the differences between people who should be on the same team. For now, the more time I spend in Africa, the more attractive I find the messy, contradictory, imperfect solutions that stop the fighting. They may not tackle the deep-seated injustices and may just be storing up problems for the future. They might not resolve the big issues, but it stops people dying. Just ask the 130,000 people displaced by the LRA.

This tension between advocacy and humanitarian organisations in Sudan will be one of the key themes in a book I am writing to be published by Reportage Press.

]]>
http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/saving_darfur_the_international_criminal_court_and_the_language_of_righting_wrongs/feed/ 2
Catching Up http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/catching_up/ http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/catching_up/#respond Wed, 14 Jan 2009 11:04:43 +0000 http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/dev/?p=3983 Back from holiday and now trying to catch up on email, phone messages and blog posts that I missed during the past fortnight. Meskel Square offers a guide to Sudan’s year ahead

The wildcards The International Criminal Court This is the only thing people are talking and thinking about in Sudan right now. What will happen when, as widely expected, the global court turns Sudan’s president into a wanted man? Expected: Any day now President Obama Will he follow President Bush’s lead and keep the "normalisation" talks going with Sudan? Or will he follow President Clinton’s lead and start ordering missile strikes on pharmaceutical factories? Expected: 20/01/2009

I’ve been enjoying Wronging Rights: Very serious commentary on very important issues for some time now. There are frankly enough pompous, self-serving blogs about genocide, misery and African development so Wronging Rights always brings a refreshing new take. If you can’t laugh about human suffering, what can you do? Take this recent example… Because Sometimes an Anti-Genocide T-Shirt Just Isn’t Enough

Does your distaste for the targeted slaughter of entire groups of people compel you to do more than wear one of our (oh-so-trendy) "I [do not heart] Genocide" t-shirts? Do you feel the need to take a bolder, more committed stance? Will your justifiable feelings of outrage carry you through the arduous process of clicking on a link, waiting for a page to load, and then clicking on a "vote" button?

Primal Sneeze always makes me smile too…

For a couple of months now I have been hearing pub-talk about signs appearing on building sites in Poland saying “No Irish”. A kickback to the “No Irish need apply” signs that appeared in the UK after the war and the “No Irish, No Blacks, No Dogs” signs on boarding houses in the 1960s.

As does Ourman in Cameroon, who’s experience of Africa seems eerily similar to mine (albeit with worse food)

Things to look out for if you want your Spotter’s Badge: * The roadside second hand clothes store – you want clothes here – they’re going to be second hand. * The dust – it’s everywhere right now and will only get worse. My colleague swears it will not rain again till March 15th. If that’s when it’s due then I’ll imagine it won’t actually start till April. People here are still organising New Year parties. * The furniture maker and his sofas (where I got mine). * The (also) second hand kitchen appliances * The Nesquik van

So that’s Google Reader almost cleared. Now for the 47 messages on my phone…

]]>
http://www.beta.frontlineclub.com/catching_up/feed/ 0